The Maritime Hotel at 363 West 16th Street, New York, New York.

GOOD: Good Beds (slept well), awesome location right across Chelsea Market, 5 minute walk from High Line. Compact yet functional rooms (table with chairs), good toiletries, all rooms have a large porthole window with view, pet friendly, quiet lobby, excellent housekeeping.
BAD: Direct facing 9th Ave therefore especially loud street noise (light sleepers bring earplugs). All rooms have 1 bed so rooms cannot accommodate 4 adults.
HIGHLY recommend this hotel for a low key and simple Manhattan stay.

This is an authentic full service welcoming hotel. It's marine them is well set by design, not by simply hanging a picture of a boat and some blue painted walls. The rooms are cozy, wonderful bed, gym, restaurant, bikes you can use. The front desk is friendly and quick with service. It is well worth the money when staying in NY. Besides, Chelsea Market is basically across the street.